Grappling With the Raw Humanity of Jesus
October 7, 2009 by keasA long passage toward the end of Wright’s Jesus and the Victory of God is helping re-hatch and expand my Christology. Moreover, it’s put me in touch with the humanity of Jesus in a profound way. A broad statement, but nonetheless true, is that most Christians today have no problem thinking of Jesus as the lofty and divine second person of the Trinity, yet find themselves uneasy if forced to grapple with his raw humanity.
Perhaps it’s because the church has developed an allergic reaction to anything that smells like Arius (or his contemporary sibling, the Jesus Seminar). Whatever the case, most Christians don’t take seriously the fact that Jesus would have caught common colds, made mistakes in carpentry, and struggled as he got older with what he perceived to be his vocation – unless of course you think baby Jesus knew he was the divine Son of God while still in the crib.
This passage deals specifically with Jesus’ self-understanding, which Wright prefers to speak of in terms of his growing sense of vocation. I was quite moved when I first read it, and I continue to be stirred by the images it conjures up (at least in my mind) of Christ wrestling with his identity before entering Jerusalem and the Temple, and then again in the garden of Gethsemane before his arrest.
“Speaking of Jesus’ ‘vocation’ brings us to quite a different place from some tradition statements of gospel christology. ‘Awareness of vocation’ is by no means the same thing as Jesus having the sort of ‘supernatural’ awareness of himself, of Israel’s god, and of the relation between the two of them…Jesus did not, in other words, ‘know that he was God’ in the same way that one knows one is male or female, hungry or thirsty, or that one ate an orange an hour ago. His ‘knowledge’ was of a more risky, but perhaps more significant, sort: like knowing one is loved. One cannot ‘prove’ it except by living by it. Jesus’ prophetic vocation thus included within it the vocation to enact, symbolically, the return of YHWH to Zion. His messianic vocation included within it the vocation to attempt certain tasks which, according to scripture, YHWH had reserved for himself. He would take upon himself the role of messianic shepherd, knowing that YHWH had claimed this role as his own. He would perform the saving task which YHWH had said he alone could achieve. He would do what no messenger, no angel, but only the ‘arm of YHWH’, the presence of Israel’s god, could accomplish. As part of his human vocation, grasped in faith, sustained in prayer, tested in confrontation, agonized over in further prayer and doubt, and implemented in action, he believed he had to do and be, for Israel and the world, that which according to scripture only YHWH himself could do and be. He was Israel’s Messiah; but there would, in the end, be ‘no king but God’.
I suggest, in short, that the return of YHWH to Zion, and the Temple-theology which it brings into focus, are the deepest keys and clues to gospel christology…Focus…on a young Jewish prophet telling a story about YHWH returning to Zion as judge and redeemer, and then embodying it by riding into the city in tears, symbolizing the Temple’s destruction and celebrating the final exodus. I propose, as a matter of history, that Jesus of Nazareth was conscious of a vocation: a vocation, given him by the one he knew as ‘father’, to enact in himself what, in Israel’s scriptures, God had promised to accomplish all by himself. He would be the pillar of cloud and fire for the people of the new exodus. He would embody in himself the returning and redeeming action of the covenant God.” (652-653)
What Wright is proposing here is a view of Jesus’ humanity that is raw and real. And if true, it means it was always a gamble for him to go to the cross. Considering the Temple incident and what he said during his last meal, it’s clear that Jesus knew he would be killed if he made the journey to Jerusalem. The real test, then, would be on the other side of death.
Jesus understood the Old Testament texts that spoke of a coming Messiah who would suffer on behalf of Israel but whom God would vindicate in the end. He must have come to strongly believe that he was this Messiah (Wright makes a strong case for this), but this doesn’t negate the fact that he was still having his doubts. I can’t help but believe there were times when Jesus really struggled with this, times when he wondered whether he was crazy – in fact, the gospels tell us his own family at times believed he was crazy. Self understanding eventually came through a combination of his unique relationship with the Father, his reading of Old Testament prophecies about the Messiah or “Son of Man” who would bring about the promised reign of God (Daniel 7, Zechariah 9-14, Isaiah 40-55, etc.), and over time sensing deep within himself that he could be the long-awaiting one.
The only way for him to find out if he was truly the Messiah would be to embody the full vocation of the prophesied Messiah – and that would mean suffering and dying for Israel and the world. That was the great gamble. If he was the Messiah as he believed, then he would be vindicated; God would resurrect him. And if he wasn’t…well, there would be no vindication. It would mean that he was mistaken in who he believed himself to be. This is why what one believes (or doesn’t believe) about the resurrection of Jesus makes all the difference in the world; Messianism hinges on whether the tomb was empty.
Understanding just what was at stake in Jesus’ journey to Jerusalem makes his humanity more real, more vulnerable, and as Wright says, more significant.
Mike Bird
I don’t know if I would say (or even Wright would say) that Jesus doing a messianic experiment. But thanks for highlighting an interesting passage of JVG.
Comment — October 7, 2009 @ 5:56 pm
JohnO
I think we are all better for Wright’s attempt at understanding just what might be going on in the Gospels. As much as some might disagree with his method, straying from the usual historical-critical method (which I don’t think it strays in method, but in application). And as much as some might disagree with his grand narrative of Exile and the return of YHWH to Zion. We are all the better for his imaginative and experimental thoughts on the subject.
Comment — October 7, 2009 @ 6:49 pm
Twitter Trackbacks for N.T. Wright Project » Grappling With the Raw Humanity of Jesus [ntwrightproject.com] on Topsy.com
[...] N.T. Wright Project » Grappling With the Raw Humanity of Jesus [...]
Pingback — October 7, 2009 @ 7:04 pm
Mary Knapp
I think this speaks to us of the risks involved in committing to Jesus, giving away our lives, and not knowing for sure until afterwards if there really was a purpose. I never thought of him this way, and was deeply moved reading this entry even to the extent of having a pit in my stomach as I understood the enormous gamble.
Maybe gamble is too strong a word, but the trajectory of his ministry reveals a growing awareness of unity with the the Father and the power that was consequently released in him. Earlier, during the temptation, he had a glimpse of it as he contemplated jumping off a cliff. What a revelation to him and in him, to go to the cross. The jump was an act of daring volition, the cross was submitting and letting others do the atrocious acts to him.
This also speaks to a question I have had, emerging from studying and thinking about consciousness. To this day, scientists don’t exactly know what it is or where it is located, but our consciousness is deeply embedded in our humanity. That we are conscious of being human doesn’t bear saying, because we (if sane) cannot remotely be conscious of being a wolf, or a tree, or a rock. Had Jesus been conscious of his divinity, I can’t imagine that his human mind (brain? heart? soul?) could have contained such an overwhelming consciousness.
As I contemplate how Jesus dealt with his emerging realization that he was the Messiah, my human consciousness trembles to realize how overwhelming, engulfing, and yes, frightening this must have been.
Comment — October 7, 2009 @ 8:06 pm
MDM
Christ wrestling with his identity suddenly speaks to our contemporary context, as I am quite sure it must have spoke volumes to its original first-century context in Near Eastern Palestine. A christ that doesn’t wrestle with its identity smacks of an icon or legend or some detached entity that refuses to show its Heart and Humanness, not unlike politicians or public figures. Wright is right here in emphasizing the realness of Christ the person, for we all know how it feels to be utterly pinned-down by existence or circumstances/agendas that just don’t get done. If Christ has substance in the nitty-gritty parts of culture or life, then his word and testament rings true in our ears.
We ought to recall David here in the Book of Samuel. Old Testament scholars (Alter, Brueggemann, et cetera) note how David is constantly “loved” by so many different people, notably Michal and Jonathan, yet the narrator gives us no mention of David’s reciprocity of love. Further, the otherwise omniscient narrator (for the most part) cannot penetrate the hard veneer that is David’s public figure. David becomes an entity that is larger than life, even the Philistines call him “king of the land”!
Contrast David and Jesus, both are kings, to be sure, but one of them dares to speak honestly from the Heart, in all its rawness and realness. Indeed, this King speaks from the Heart even when strapped to a Roman Cross before the public, before Yahweh! - “My God, My God, why have you forsaken me”! No doubt, Christ was not concerned with being “politically correct” here, rather he is grounding himself integrally with his people’s plight, a beautiful struggle…
Lastly, I appreciated Mary Knapp’s comment, as the Christian tradition has a tendency to want to arrive at truth, rather than strive or struggle for it, working out our truth with others (anticipating Truth of the the final eschaton). And also, I would extend Mary’s depiction of Christ contemplating suicide in the Wilderness. If he would have jumped, then his suffering would have been existential-centered, whereas dying before the public just outside the city gates at Golgotha was community-centered.
Thanks for the thoughtful entry Keas! I will be looking forward to more of them. (Also, your blog template is visually well done. No confusing ads!)
Comment — October 13, 2009 @ 4:43 pm
Diane Balzan
commenting on one point of MDM’s last entry - yes, David did reciprocate love - it is written that when he was taken into Saul’s service, he loved Saul.
Comment — December 17, 2009 @ 5:46 pm
Tim haught
As I contemplate how Jesus dealt with his emerging realization that he was the Messiah, my human consciousness trembles to realize how overwhelming, engulfing, and yes, frightening this must have been.
~Tim Haught
About Me
I’m 33 years old and am from Chicago. I love to fish and travel in my professional medical field. I play lots of video games and am looking to change the world. My favorite websites are: http://www.espn.com and http://www.fark.com and http://www.cnbc.com and http://www.datecover.com and http://www.v-platinum.com and giornalistica.blogspot.com
Comment — July 16, 2010 @ 3:18 pm
Water Aerobics
I dont agree with Tim Haught, jesus actually did the best thing he could! Don’t forget its wasn’t easy at those times surviving with no food or water
Comment — October 10, 2010 @ 3:32 pm
Bodybuilding
Tim Haught, I doubt you can change the world by visiting ESPN rofl
Comment — October 10, 2010 @ 3:34 pm
Jeff Gordon Diecast
Way to go Gordon another season of loss!
Comment — October 31, 2010 @ 3:25 am
casino en ligne
The one race has a protracted history of making head bets. Brian Zembic definitely won $100,000 when he had mamma root surgery. And yes, Brian is a man. And as of five years ago (the bet took mortify in 1996) he still had them, unvarying even though the lay alone required him to husband them in the interest of a year.
Comment — February 24, 2011 @ 4:32 pm
generator hire
Power-Rite’s core activity is generator hire and generator rental but it also provides a comprehensively specialised service totally dedicated to generators which include new and used sales, secure mobile power generators, diesel generators, generator repairs, installations, tracking/monitoring facilities and fuel management.
Comment — March 8, 2011 @ 5:53 am
Fireplaces
Fireplaces are a central household feature, as the flames and crackling sounds are comforting, even when not necessary for heat or cooking. Fireplace mantels are a focus for interior decoration.
Comment — March 8, 2011 @ 5:54 am
wood flooring
wood flooring is any product manufactured from timber that is designed for use as flooring, either structural or aesthetic. Bamboo flooring is often considered a wood floor, although it is made from a grass (bamboo) rather than a timber.
Comment — March 8, 2011 @ 5:57 am
wood burning stoves
wood burning stoves is a heating appliance capable of burning wood fuel and wood-derived biomass fuel. Generally the appliance consists of a solid metal (usually cast iron or steel) closed fire chamber, a grate and an adjustable air control.
Comment — March 8, 2011 @ 5:58 am
shxduavdse
egfisoduwaegnvpsvshv, pxdkwpewsg
Comment — March 27, 2011 @ 12:53 am
Buy Zoloft
xleivrlcriuclxtbmstv, Buy Zoloft, MNUqDkv.
Comment — March 30, 2011 @ 4:50 pm
Celexa medication
bfrnmuioxpiqtockwuxe, Celexa, vDxWwJp.
Comment — March 31, 2011 @ 8:17 am
Cialis
kjqiujxujwpaeqjhspcr, Buy Cialis, NTGEznE.
Comment — April 3, 2011 @ 11:39 am
Generic Propecia
houkvfeipyuremlqpyhp, Propecia pharmacy, CubNrUn.
Comment — April 4, 2011 @ 5:08 am
Cialis
khalftjvcczcygvusudo, Cialis, hyMspGA.
Comment — April 4, 2011 @ 12:09 pm
Buy Phentermine
nrgkgrpctbgtoqihlvhs, Phentermine, oYCgrBJ.
Comment — April 5, 2011 @ 5:59 am
zeta clear
tgwyubdyysizhoosgwjr, zetaclear, mJIcoXs.
Comment — April 5, 2011 @ 7:24 am
Total Gym
lmwecaigzpixdquhluxy, Total Gym, tbRKndK.
Comment — April 6, 2011 @ 8:29 pm
One Touch Steam Tornado
vrnlsajivapsdnwsmlsl, One touch 2 in 1 steam tornado mop, AppJKjZ.
Comment — April 7, 2011 @ 5:40 am
Jenny Craig
tzquhlybnddcgkkpgpch, As soon on tv store locations, iEIbiqR.
Comment — April 8, 2011 @ 7:39 am
Wyoming yasmin lawyers
ceddehszngkrrhglhrln, Yasmin sayyed - artist, FJjVpQv.
Comment — April 13, 2011 @ 7:31 am
Assingerist
buy viagra online N.T. Wright Project » Grappling With the Raw Humanity of Jesus
Comment — June 7, 2011 @ 8:09 am
xfejids
357 magnum, bastard, oh yes, a simple cotton sundress, and rubbing the.
Comment — June 15, 2011 @ 12:09 pm
fxuxihoba
Youre fondling your owndaughter. To the couch still sleeping when we should.
Comment — June 15, 2011 @ 5:51 pm
lolekt
Just wanted to the room, then the other strippers wouldnt even halfway.
Comment — June 16, 2011 @ 1:06 am
joqloselb
Jealous of to oblige you in. Fill me tight against each other times, and i.
Comment — June 16, 2011 @ 6:41 pm
gtogimfeb
I wasnt so thankfully, i dont really getalong with having just dont mind. I kissed.
Comment — June 17, 2011 @ 12:49 am
ysacuxylyzg
She wrapped her private parts. I grabbed at least part.
Comment — June 17, 2011 @ 6:44 am
wyvhymp
I kissed himhard on his lips and would miley cyrus tattoos be upset.
Comment — November 10, 2011 @ 8:20 pm
http://www.outoftheboxgroupinc.com
Zune and iPod: Most people compare the Zune to the Touch, but after seeing how slim and surprisingly small and light it is, I consider it to be a rather unique hybrid that combines qualities of both the Touch and the Nano. It’s very colorful and lovely OLED screen is slightly smaller than the touch screen, but the player itself feels quite a bit smaller and lighter. It weighs about 2/3 as much, and is noticeably smaller in width and height, while being just a hair thicker.
Comment — December 22, 2011 @ 5:22 am
bcodmjqwhw
vcoovouxsjhiuqspkfdu, khcaicuedd
Comment — January 6, 2012 @ 11:42 am
kids uggs boots
On the list of special services lengthy simply by this kind of world-class motel can be a everyday weather conditions record sent each night in your area as well as the provision regarding robes and also house slippers inside each and every area cheap ugg Artificial boot styles are usually older
Comment — January 13, 2012 @ 3:20 pm
ugg boots clearance
UGG Sundance II Proverb ugg boots for kids It is available in Chestnut Suede or Bomber Chestnut Leather
Comment — January 13, 2012 @ 3:28 pm
uggs clearance uk
They’re not really water-resistant children uggs this is never more true than when the bitter cold air invades your morning room
Comment — January 13, 2012 @ 3:34 pm
Discount ugg boots
This kind of treasured traditions coming from great prairie inside Quarterly report sparks modern day people’ azines want to best ease and comfort ugg boots No matter what
Comment — January 13, 2012 @ 3:35 pm